Wednesday, March 18, 2026
HomeBitcoinDoes Binohash grinding behave like a PoW, and is it really ASIC-resistant?

Does Binohash grinding behave like a PoW, and is it really ASIC-resistant?

I have been studying Robin Linus’s "Binohash" paper
(Binohash:transaction introspection with out softforks,https://delvingbitcoin.org/t/binohash-transaction-introspection-without-softforks/2288) and
making an attempt to know the grinding course of.

My tough understanding:

  • The spender chooses subsets of signatures
    from a set pool embedded within the locking script
  • Every subset adjustments the scriptCode through
    FindAndDelete earlier than hashing
  • The objective is to discover a subset the place the ensuing
    sighash satisfies a leading-zero situation

So in apply this seems to be like a search drawback
over combinatorial subsets moderately than a easy
nonce house.


In comparison with Bitcoin mining:

  • Mining hashes a fixed-size header with a
    altering nonce
  • Binohash requires modifying KB-sized script
    information (through FindAndDelete) earlier than every hash
  • Every transaction defines its personal unbiased
    search house

My questions:

  1. Is it affordable to consider this as a sort
    of PoW, or is {that a} deceptive analogy?

  2. What really limits ASIC acceleration right here —
    the FindAndDelete step, the bigger enter dimension,
    or one thing else?

  3. Would a specialised ASIC nonetheless present
    important speedup, or is that this inherently
    nearer to a GPU-style workload?

  4. Does the truth that every transaction defines
    its personal search house make this essentially
    non-competitive, in contrast to mining the place everybody
    races on the identical puzzle?

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments